Sunday, June 05, 2005

Sqeeze play

The New York Times has a story about the Department of Education raising the bar on who can receive financial aid and at what level.

The argument is basically that better economic times are ahead and so the families can bear a greater portion of the costs of college education. The problem is that the economic forecasts tend to be more optimistic than not and actually penalizes single-parent families more than two-parent families.


NY Times' Analysis


Given the esteemed position education and increasing opportunity for more Americans has in this administration's rhetoric, it leaves one to wonder where the leadership is on this. Higher education degrees hold the place that high school diplomas once held. Forcing families to bear increasing amount of the cost saddles them with additional burdens and leaves them even more vulnerable to unexpected crisis and the rising costs of other necessities such as the nearly exponential rise in medical insurance rates.

The idea behind financial aid is to provide greater opportunity. If the economic forecast is as rosy as is being predicted, shouldn't that lead to greater income for the government as well, thus allowing them to reduce or eliminate the raise?

- Murphy

Friday, June 03, 2005

Truth? What do we care about truth...

Wired magazine's online site, Wired News, has a story describing one patient's outrage at a Florida politician using her situation to oppose stem-cell research.
A spinal-cord patient has charged that Rep. Dave Weldon (R-Florida) used her image without permission and misled Congress and the public by suggesting that her case offers evidence that adult stem cells can help severely injured people walk again.

Susan Fajt, who suffered a spinal-cord injury in a car accident in November 2001 that left her with little sensation from her chest down, e-mailed Weldon, who is also a physician, on Wednesday detailing her complaints and requesting an apology.

She believes Weldon's comments and his use of her image gave patients and lawmakers, who were about to vote on a bill that would approve funding for embryonic stem-cell research, the false impression that adult stem-cell therapy can cure spinal-cord injuries.

"This poster is of a young lady who was paralyzed for years and had an adult stem-cell transplant," Weldon said that day. "She is able to stand up."
Fajt received adult stem cells from her nasal passage in an experimental procedure to improve her paralysis. While Fajt has since had some limited improvement, no one is sure if it was due to the stem cells or not.

Fajt supports research in all areas of the stem cell field and is angry that she would be used in such a way.
"If Weldon wouldn't have used me and said a cure is going to be found with adult stem-cell research, embryonic stem-cell research may have been federally funded," Fajt said in an interview.


This is yet an addition example of the anti-intellectual and anti-science tendency in the conservative community and the lengths to which they will go to deny the facts to the voters and the people.

At the very least there are complex issues that must be addressed but they require absolute clarity and complete access to the facts involved. The conservatives in this country place ideology over facts to the detriment of us all. Most of them demonstrate little to no understanding of the issues or what is at stake.

Here in Missouri we have had to deal with the return of creationism in schools, deceptive teachings in sex education as well as the continuing debate over stem cell research.

Much of the stem-cell debate does lie in the realm of the ethical, but using deceptive practices to further your cause does nothing to improve our understanding of the issue.

But is it even possible to debate ethics with those who deny facts that disagree with their world view?

- Murphy

Thursday, June 02, 2005

Oil and the Economy

Kevin Drum has been doing a good analysis of the "Peak Oil" question (the point at which oil production begins to decline due to declining available supplies in the ground) that looms over the global economy. It's a multi-part series, but his most recent post on this topic makes the most important point for both conservationists, economists and world leaders.

His basic point is: We may not have hit peak oil yet, but production has maxed out. The major oil-influenced economic shocks come not from high prices, but from sudden price spikes. Since there is little to no excess capacity left in the world, the market is more susceptible to price shocks than ever before. Even small shocks can trigger disproportionate effects due to the lack of wiggle-room that was previously provided by Saudi Arabia's enormous (now nearly maxed out) production capability.

As he points out, no one knows for sure if the peak is already here or if it will take until 2035 or later to arrive. However, increasing volatility is inevitable and given the large role oil plays in the global economy, we can expect nasty surprises. Unless we plan for it. As Kevin points out, the economies can survive high oil prices, and they may even spur innovations to develop more elastic alternatives to oil. Market forces are able to take care of this, but we must begin taking it seriously and begin planning for higher prices.

Some thought also needs to be given to India and China's rapidly growing demand. It will quickly surpass U.S. demand and keep climbing.

- Murphy

Wednesday, June 01, 2005

I missed this editorial in the Post-Dispatch the other day, but it hits on two important topics: the potential real estate bubble and the growing national debt. Even better, they link the two together. Some have drawn attention to one or the other, but the two are linked.

Both Americans and the nation are in debt up to our eyeballs. A population willing to rack up debt to pay for its consumption is not likely to spend much time worrying when their government does the same. However, eventually bills come due.

We talk a good game when it comes to fiscal responsibility, but the truth is that we rarely follow our own advice. The economy runs on consumption which is financed by debt (home equity loans, credit cards, etc.), the government also runs on debt (treasury bonds continuously purchased by Asian central banks). The question is...what happens when we get behind or the creditors are no longer willing to extend their credit? For individuals it means bankruptcy and years spent trying to get out of the hole (before the current Congress changed it, individuals could write off certain amounts of debt, now it never goes away). For the nation it means a recession.

Previously we all strived to save money, both individually and nationally, now we have a miniscule savings rate and an administration that has tossed off the goal of achieving surpluses. We may be able to get by on this path, as long as the line of credit continues. If something were to destabilize things, however, we may find ourselves looking up out of a very deep hole.

- Murphy

Bellweather

Joe Mannies of the Post-Dispatch has a story examining the similarity between the Missouri Republican Party's fight over stem cell research and the national debate among Republicans.

Also of interest in the story is the shifting weight in the state Republican Party, away from St. Louis and back to the more rural parts of the state. Until recently, many of the top Republicans were based in the St. Louis area.

- Murphy

Tuesday, May 31, 2005

Capital deficit

President Bush famously said he had political capital to burn. Many, including supporters and opponents, thought the statement may come back to haunt him, well I am sure there are times these days when he may think he can hear the echo.

The statement was typical Bush. In some ways it may have reflected a certain amount of truth. His victory was not a rousing mandate, but enough people decided to back him even though they questioned many of his policies including taking the nation to war in Iraq and were aware of the questionable use of intelligence in the selling of the war. A mandate it might not have been, but it certainly must have looked like a blank check to Bush and Rove.

A story in today's Washington Post raised the specter of the dreaded "Lame Duck" term. Bush may have squeaked through the election, but the people who once supported him are starting to have some buyers remorse. His polling numbers continue their downward slide and the President's number one policy initiative, Social Security privatization, has hit a brick wall, hard.

Even members of his own party are openly challenging the President's agenda. The recent move by Republican moderates (a relative term now) in the Senate nuclear option debate was a direct challenge to the Bill Frist/Tom DeLay-run Republican party. While they may have been raising their own status a bit, the move reflects a growing disgruntlement with a party leadership that seems more and more to be the political wing of the religious conservatives, to paraphrase the Republican former Senator, John Danforth.

That most of the recent slippage has occurred in the domestic arena is unsurprising. Since taking office, Bush's domestic agenda has taken a lot of heat from both the policy watchers and the public. The national security and foreign policy question, which many cite as pulling the President through the election, is a more vague area that many voters are unfamiliar with and are more willing to trust the administration due to their own lack of knowledge.

When it comes to the home-front, however, even the President's most popular ideas (e.g. No Child Left Behind) take a lot more scrutiny. People are comfortable dealing with their schools, retirement programs and grocery costs. They see the effects first-hand and are much more willing to take politicians to task when they start to tinker with them. A failing school and rising food costs are much more tangible than international diplomacy.

The more nuanced and concrete world of domestic policy is less affected by tough-guy rhetoric. The "compassionate conservativism" that Bush ran on in 2000 is resonates with more individuals, but its roots in liberal policies (medicare, social security, education funding) does not muster the rabid support among Bush's base, the base he is most able to motivate when challenging terrorists to "bring it on". He may, in fact, split his own support.

Republican congressmen seem to be picking up on this and as the President's focus turns inward to domestic issues, they are less willing to tow the administration's line and are demanding changes to the President's agenda. The social security privatization move has become such an albatross that some members of congress opt to stay in Washington when the President comes to their district, not the sign of healthy leadership.

The more moderate reality of the American people seems to deny the Republican leadership's cocksure assertion that they are the future of American politics and will never again return to the minority. While the Republican Party has made enormous gains in the past decade, they have done so by adopting liberal language that cloaks their true policy beliefs and the result of which has been a backlash against the party, mostly those in Congress. The Democrats faced a similar situation in the early nineties, a backlash that led to the Republican gains in Congress led by Newt Gingrich and his "Contract with America."

Bush has 3 1/2 years to go in his term and to discount the unquestioning support he inspires in people would be a bad move for the Democrats. They should focus on breaking the Republican control of Congress and highlight the Republican policies that are in fact out of step with the majority of Americans. The Social Security example is a perfect opportunity. Despite all the smoke, the people seem to realize that the President wanted to end a program that is arguably the most successful (certainly the most popular) government program in history. They should tie the Republicans to that lead balloon and proudly embrace their role as Social Security's protectors.

In the end, people support most of the domestic programs that have been enacted over the past century. The Bush wing of the Republican party (the Grover Norquist/"the business of government is business" wing) oppose the New Deal and Great Society programs that have been so successful and popular, and use deflective language to cover their actions to eliminate them.

The Bush administration would do well to mind the will of the people. A mistaken belief in one's own righteousness has hastened the fall of countless people and parties.

- Murphy

Deep Throat!

He has finally revealed himslelf, or has he? Woodward and Bernstein refuse to comment on whether former FBI agent V. Mark Felt is the most famous source in journalism. They have, in the past, said others were not the man the made Nixon squirm, yet they are mum on Felt. NPR's Talk of the Nation covered the story today and the facts seem to fit. They say his family encouraged him to out himself before he dies. Felt is apparently very illl and in his 90's.

Woodward and Bernstien are sticking to their guns and refuse to reveal their most celebrated source until after the source passes on.

- Murphy



Update: Woodward, Berstein and Bradlee confirm that Felt is Deep Throat.

Tuesday, May 24, 2005

Roundup of responses

Here is an incomplete list of some responses to yesterday's deal regarding the judicial nominees:



After reading some of the analysis it looks as if the Democrats did manage to do more than just establish a holding action.

I still maintain, however, that the main point is that the Republican majority is actively working to eliminate any check on its power. The apoplectic response by some on the right illustrates the true motive behind the move. They saw this as a chance to further restrict Democratic resistance to their programs. Instead several Senators, for one reason or another, bucked the pressure of the increasingly strident right and avoided signing on with the nuclear option (a term Jonah Goldberg admits was coined by a Republican, supposedly Trent Lott, though Goldberg doesn't say) a move that is guaranteed to generate some right-wing heat for them.

- Murphy

When is compromise not compromise?

When only one side gives up ground, its not compromise. There are attempts all over to get a sense of who got the better end of the deal. On the whole I think it is not as bad as some think, but I don't see it as an actual win for the Democrats, it seems more of a holding action. The Republicans were able to get the three most controversial judicial nominees through and the Democrats get to keep a weakened filibuster. It may have been the best option the Dems could get in the short term, but unless the moderate Republicans are willing to stand by their seeming commitment to support more broadly accepted nominees in the future, we are likely to see this standoff again.

In the end the real point has been overlooked. The Republican majority threatened override the rules of the Senate (which state that 2/3 majority is required to change the rules) in order to change the eliminate rules that put limits on their power. It would have an abandonment over 200 years of precedence as well as a clear departure from the intent of the framers of the constitution.

This was not a debate over nominees but whether the majority party in the Senate has to right to overturn the rules in order to expand its power. The rules on the matter are clear, just as the Republicans are clear about their interest in shirking any and all limits to their power.

This agreement is a patch, this issue will continue to raise its head until responsible individuals who respect the framework of the government are elected.

- Murphy

Monday, May 23, 2005

No beer?

Local Teamsters are setting up picket lines in select locations to protest contract problems with Lohr Distributing, Anheuser-Busch's distributor. Picket sites may include Busch Stadium. Needless to say, there will be no beer deliveries today from Lohr.

- Murphy