Wednesday, July 27, 2005

Ba dum bum...

The press releases from City Hall are beginning lean increasingly towards self-parody..
For example, "Rainford Agrees with the newspaper today."

- Murphy

Monday, July 25, 2005

Atheist Summer Camp

ABC News has a report on a summer camp that was set up to cater to the children of atheist, agnostic, or merely secular families.

One issue they address in the television report that isn't in the web version is the hostility directed towards those who are up-front about their lack of adherence to a faith (although atheism could be defined as a theology).

In a country in which a declaration of belief is almost a mandatory requirement to hold any elected position above the level of alderman, the exposure of the growing hostility directed towards those who don't support the intimate commingling of faith and public life is needed.

For a nation founded on a tolerance of different ideas about faith, and a nation whose major religion's dominant theme also revolves around loving your neighbor despite your differences, the growing hostility from those on the Christian right is disturbing.

- Murphy

Armstrong not a true Athlete?

One of the commentators on KSDK's Sports Plus said that he didn't believe that Lance Armstrong was a real athlete, just a good cyclist. He rambled on about one qualification is that you have to be able to do more than sport and that he could probably take Armstrong in a game of one-on-one.

He cited Michael Jordan as an athlete, rightly so, but qualified it by pointing out that Jordan played baseball in addition to basketball. Anyone who remembers Jordan's short-lived baseball career will realize that this gentleman simply doesn't like cyclists.

I am not a cycling fan, but anyone who spends any time watching Armstrong race will see that he is indeed a superb athlete and a world-class competitor. For seven years the best people in his chosen field have been trying to beat him and every time they get close, he finds another gear and takes off. It's like watching Albert Pujols in a clutch situation.

How this gentleman became a sports analyst is beyond me.

If anyone knows his name, please post it in the comments. I only caught the end of the show and they didn't mention the guests names at the closing.

- Murphy

Sunday, July 24, 2005

4th District

The political eye levels its gaze on the 4th Senate District. However, its conclusion is the same as everyone else's, its totally in the air until the all the field shakes out and we know who is in for sure. Even then its going to be a messy, divisive election.

- Murphy

Thursday, July 21, 2005

Donnyblogging

All material is paraphrased.

On Supreme Court Appointment
Amy White: "[Roberts] is a grand slam"

Alvin Reed: He's a friend of the administration. He has a very short record.

White: A short record is better, that way you don't have Senator Kennedy with days worth of questions; how do you see this issue, how do you see that issue.

Charlie Brennan: I think it's good that people have lots of information.

Martin Dugan: The President of the United States' decision should be respected.

Brennan: It’s not only the President’s country

The Blunt, Pro-Life Split
Bill McClellan: Blunt openly supported stem-cell research during his campaign.

White: Blunt cut a deal with the Pro-Life community that he wouldn’t block anti-stem cell research legislation

McClellan: It's on [the pro-life groups] if they had a secret deal. Blunt did not hide his support for stem-cell research.

Reed: It was business as usual. Blunt was pro-life until it the business interests stepped in. It was a dollar and sense decision. He didn't hide the fact that he was pro-research.

White: Between the business interests and traditional pro-life supporters, business won.

Brennan: The pro-life politicians always pick around the edges, why don't they go big if they are really serious.

Dugan: Roe v. Wade says the state officials can’t make it illegal.

Reed: [If Roe were defeated]There are people who feel strongly enough that they would relocate over this issue. We want the smartest and the brightest. The smartest and the brightest would avoid a state that takes the step to make abortion illegal. Not necessarily for their support of abortion, but because of the intrusiveness of anti-abortion law.

White: You are saying that its not the brightest and the smartest who would look at an ultrasound and decide to keep the child?

On Amy White’s Column on the Lucas Park Homeless
Reed: A few thousand homeless people are not going to derail progress, I don't buy it.

McClellan: The child care center and the homless in Lucas Park have coexisted for years.

Brennan: We need to build a place for the homeless to be taken care of. I;m the only one on this panel advocating for the homeless. Others are arguing to maintain the status quo.

White: The Slay administration is trying to find a way to address the issue. They are working to find a solution.


Teamsters’ Strike
Brennan: St. Louisans don't always root for the little guy. St. Louisans tend to like the establishment.

McClellan & Reed: Many St. Louisans don’t support the Teamsters because the don’t see them as the little guy.

McClellan: This is not about the striking workers wanting more, but keeping what they have. There may be a thousand people lining up for this job, but it is not about finding the lowest level people will work for.

- Murphy

Good soldier Shimkus

Representative John Shimkus (R-IL) continues the Republican cover story that Valerie Plame was not a covert agent. He was on The Charile Brennan Show on KMOX radio this morning talking to Charlie and talking some calls from constituents.

When asked about the Rove controversy Shimkus said that at the heart is whether Plame was a covert agent at the time. Shimkus said that, "no one has said she was."

The CIA obviously took the matter of Plame being identified as an operative serious enough to ask for an investigation. The Justice Department has obviously determined there is enough evidence of a crime that they are willing to jail reporters in order to get their indictment. A State Department memo to Colin Powell and potentially circulated on Air Force One indicated that the information that Ambassador Joe Wilson's wife, Valerie Plame worked for the CIA was listed as secret.

If that is not enough evidence that she was operating under cover, I don't know what it would take to convince someone.

- Murphy

Speculation

The Columbia Journalism Review's Echo Chamber has a biting take on the the Tuesday's rumor-mongering about possible Supreme Court nominee, Judge Edith Clement (5th Circuit). I will admit I talked about her myself. My girlfriend and I speculated about her and others, but If someone had pinned me down, however, I would have gone with either Roberts or Judge J. Michael Luttig. It wasn't my original thinking, but I would have put some money on them after reading a profile of Roberts and Luttig in theWashington Post. In the end we agreed to instead go watch baseball over some beer and greek food. Like most people we knew we'd find out in a few hours anyhow so why worry.

The Echo Chamber piece is a dead-on description of the flailing about the major news outlets engage in when they don't have flashy news spoon-fed to them.

Considering the enormous resources any one of these news-gathering organizations have, how can they not pack every minute of the day with well-researched, in-depth stories about the world we live in?

There are undergraduate students who write papers overnight with more meat to them than the limp, incomplete pap that is thrown at the viewers.

There are hundreds if not thousands of journalism students out there who would spend 12 hour days doing the legwork, interviews and research, if they could just get a crack at it. Instead you have the bobbleheads pontificating and speculating about stories they are too lazy to familiarize themselves with.

Many people have little time in the day to spend digging through various newspapers and magazines to get an in-depth grasp of a subject. They often rely on the television news media to get them up to speed. Instead they have this echo chamber bouncing half-thoughts off each other to see which one makes them seem the smartest.

They seem surprised when over 50% of the American people believe that Saddam and Al-Qaeda were in league together after they spent months allowing the administration to make the unchecked allusion (if not the outright assertion) that they collaborated to attack the World Trade Center. They then allow the administration to come out and state, "we never said there was a link," even though they had clearly given that impression to the American people.

If the cable news channels were held to the standards that a good journalism class is held to, they would fail.

Speculation and rumor fuel the cycle with not a research staff in sight. If they would even bring on an expert or two that didn't make their living appearing on television as "expert" they would improve greatly. Everyone knows you get better information from the the beat cop than you do the Chief.

Critics accuse PBS and NPR of being "liberal" news outlets. While I disagree (as do the two, two, conservative ombudsmen brought in to ferret out the "liberal" agenda at the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, which funds both PBS and NPR. Their study found no bias, simply excellent reporting) they are entitled to their opinion. However, they do pack hour after hour with excellent reporting that communicates the essential meat of the story to the listener/viewer in a way that is engaging and not condescending ways. They can handle the top news of the day as well as longer, more in-depth pieces that require a more thoughtful examination. PBS and NPR are not without their own problems, and often succumb to the easy spoon fed story, but taken as a whole, it is far and above other major media outlets.

Until the major media start focusing on the news and stop trying to simply get the headline out before the other guys, the public will continue to only get half the story.

- Murphy

London Redux?

The BBC is reporting that minor blasts have caused the evacuation of the London subway. There may also be an incident involving a bus as well. No hospitals are reporting any casualties however.

A BBC correspondent is saying that the incident involved dummy bombs made of blasting caps. Blasting caps can be dangerous, but are not very powerful. They are used to trigger other explosives.

- Murphy

Wednesday, July 20, 2005

Stealth for whom?

While President Bush's nominee for the Supreme Court of the United States, John Roberts, is certainly going to receive a lot of attention for his anti-Roe v. Wade writings, it's important to remember that while the social issues can help get supporters out of bed in the morning, it is the business interests that pay the bills.
Roberts no stranger to business cases
Supreme Court pick has won major cases for Toyota, Fox

By Robert Schroeder, MarketWatch
Last Update: 3:00 PM ET July 20, 2005  

WASHINGTON (MarketWatch) - In selecting John Roberts as his Supreme Court nominee, President Bush appears to have found a candidate that will please business interests.
…
"He has an understanding of the impact of regulation and litigation on businesses," said Glenn Lammi, chief counsel of the legal studies division at the Washington Legal Foundation, a conservative group. "He has a limited-government view of things."
…
U.S. Chamber of Commerce President Thomas Donohue said Roberts is "well respected by the legal and business communities." Still, the Chamber, a powerful business group, will investigate Roberts's background.

- Murphy

Advise and consent

Lindsay Beyerstein, who is sitting in for Kevin Drum at The Washington Monthly, is exactly on point when she punctures the essential Republican argument over confirmation hearings; Supreme Court appointee or any other:
The Republicans are trying to convince the public that the president has the right to have his nominees confirmed. That's absolutely ridiculous. Regardless of what you think about the judicial filibuster, the fact remains that every senator is responsible for evaluating and critiquing the nominees (adivsing) and approving only those she deems worthy (consenting). Consent implies the choice between assent and dissent. You can't exercise consent when "consent" is your only option.
The President is not the regent. For all the talk of the importance of the Legislature as the representative of the people, when it comes to Presidential decisions the Republicans are quick to cite some super-status that provides the President with some ultimate right to operate that supersedes the system of checks and balances as created by the founders of the American government.

Extreme circumstances do not have to exist for the people's representatives to speak out against a Presidential decision.

- Murphy