Wednesday, August 17, 2005

Odd Coincidence

The Iraqi wife of a Voice of America spokesperson drove to Crawford, Texas to oppose Cindy Sheehan's calls for troop withdrawls. She said she just had to come to Crawford to ask Sheehan to stop, that the soldiers had died to free her country and that they should stay to help the Iraqi people.

She was interviewed on Hardball and her statements were reported in some news outlets.

For those who aren't aware, Voice of America is a U.S. propaganda producer. It's most famous for broadcasting to those trapped behind the Iron Curtain during the cold war. It frequently made appearances in spy novels from the period, where it would broadcast coded messages to agents.

Given the floating rumors of a possible troop reduction and the President's attempts to slap down any such speculation, the appearance of an Iraqi-American married to an employee of a U.S. propaganda operation opposing calls for a pull out certainly tingle the radar.

Don't misunderstand me, VOA has done a great job over the years and has contributed much to positive impressions of America abroad. They played a crucial role during the Cold War and will likely play as significant a role in our current struggle with militant anti-modern islamic fundamentalists and the communities they draw support from. They are an important part of our foreign diplomacy. They are not a news organization but a marketing group. That said, they don't broadcast fiction, merely properly presented press releases.

- Murphy

Tuesday, August 16, 2005

Making the grade in the Electoral College

Here's the conclusion to an interesting post by Publius over at BTC News. He's addressing some recent Democratic analysis about the electoral college.
So generally speaking the attempt to change the electoral college is a waste of time, since any change is probably going to make the problem worse. But be of good cheer. We shouldn’t be concerned with the electoral college as such anyway. If Democrats more competitive with rural voters, we would suddenly find ourselves doing better in a lot more states, and that the electoral college wouldn’t matter quite so much. Better to spend our time on something that may yield some positive results that just banging our head against the constitutional wall.
Since the 2000 election I have repeatedly heard the claim that the EC hurts the Democrat Party and should therefore be changed. That's not exactly how it is phrased, however, but that is essentially the argument. The EC represents an effective compromise that helps balance out differences between states in a federal system. It's not pretty, and it's not perfect, but it works almost all of the time.

Publius states exactly what the Democrats need to be doing. The problem does not lie with the EC but with Democrats performance in areas that are favored under the EC, large low-population states like some of the western states Bush won.

Democrats shouldn't be too quick to bash the EC, they also benefit from the system, California and New York provide substantial running room for Democratic candidates. If the system were changed, they may also lose out on some safe votes.

- Murphy

Monday, August 15, 2005

Keeping your enemies closer....

An important piece in Time Magazine documenting the increasing influence of Iran in Iraq (via Laura Rozen). It focuses on the role Iran has played in backing the Shi`ite militias both financially and with arms.

Recent caches of Iranian made explosives that have given the militants a greater punch against U.S. forces' armor has shed a stark light on their involvement. It's gotten people's attention better than the intelligence stories that have been cropping up since before the U.S. invasion.

While the administration continues to readjust its rationale for war and recast current progress in the most favorable light, the political and military calculus involved in any effort to leave a stable Iraq behind becomes increasingly complex.

There is seemingly little the U.S. could do to restrict Iranian influence in Iraq. Perhaps that has contributed to new talk of pressuring Iran over their nuclear program, especially the use of the phrase, "military option as a last resort." Certainly enough evidence has come to light that the Iraq invasion was not a use of force as a last resort, but a preordained certainty.

- Murphy

Saturday, August 13, 2005

A who's who you might not want to be on.

Think Progress runs down the roster of the 21 administration officials involved in the Plame leak investigation, everyone from the President down to his press secretaries.

They list the individual and the timeline of their involvement in the investigation. It doesn't asses the weight of their involvement, just how they are related to the case.

For anyone who doubts the seriousness of this case here's former Ken Starr deputy Sol Wisenberg, “The Bush interview ‘indicates there’s obviously a belief that the leak was at a high level." Wisenberg questioned President Clinton during the Starr investigation.

- Murphy

Thursday, August 11, 2005

Who sent Wilson?

Did Valerie Plame suggest her husband, former ambassador Joe Wilson, for the trip to investigate claims that Iraq sought to purchase uranium from Niger?

Walter Pincus has an excellent story which organizes all the known facts regarding who sent Wilson to Niger.

This has been a contentious issue but mostly for those trying to score political points. It has been raised most often by conservatives attempting to discredit Wilson's criticism of the administration.

The CIA and Wilson maintain that while Plame was involved in process, Wilson's name was chosen by others. Defenders of the administration's use of the uranium story (since proven incorrect, as Wilson's critical New York Times op-ed stated) claim that Plame sent her husband in order to discredit the administration.

What can be said for sure is that Plame did not have the power to send her husband and Wilson's criticism of the administration's use of the report he put together was proven correct very quickly. In fact, CIA Director George Tenet had his hand forced and took responsibility for the inclusion of uranium procurement claims even though the CIA and State Department worked hard to keep the claim out of the President's State of the Union speech.

Pincus' piece breaks down the timeline as well as showing that there is some good evidence that Plame, in fact, did suggest her husband for the trip despite Wilson's claim that he was picked by others.

Certainly administration defenders will jump on this, but the question of who sent Wilson is immaterial. Wilson was the last U.S. Ambassador to Iraq and had contacts in Africa and was well regarded by President Bush's father, Herbert Walker Bush. He was well qualified to lead such an investigation.

Wilson went public with the fact that his trip was being manipulated to support false claims and he and his wife were attacked as a result. They were attacked for being credible critics of the administration's fabrications.

- Murphy

Wednesday, August 10, 2005

Coup in Baghdad

Members of a Shiite militia took control of Baghdad today.
BAGHDAD, Iraq, Aug. 9 - Armed men entered Baghdad's municipal building during a blinding dust storm on Monday, deposed the city's mayor and installed a member of Iraq's most powerful Shiite militia.

The deposed mayor, Alaa al-Tamimi, who was not in his offices at the time, recounted the events in a telephone interview on Tuesday and called the move a municipal coup d'état. He added that he had gone into hiding for fear of his life.

"This is the new Iraq," said Mr. Tamimi, a secular engineer with no party affiliation. "They use force to achieve their goal."
Baghdad is not only the seat of power in Iraq, it is also a symbolic position.

The coup happened under the nose of the U.S. forces which are hunkered down in the capitol.

This does not bode well for hopes of a democratic or even benevolent form of government. The proposed drawdown of forces in time for the 2006 mid-terms may lead into even more out-right fighting between factions. It happens already, of course, but the small U.S. presence may serve as a deterrent to all-out fighting.

- Murphy

"Intelligent" proposal?

Running off something Kevin Drum wrote, if the Intelligent Design crowd has an issue with teaching the theory of evolution, how come they don't also go after the theory of relativity?

While evolution helps explain how to get from C to D, relativity explains how A happened in the first place. If you want to talk about origins of the species, how about the beginning of everything?

It reminds me of a story the physicist Steven Hawkings included in one of his books. He was presenting a paper in Rome and the late Pope John Paul II gave a talk to the assembled scientists blessing their efforts to further mankind's knowledge. He did however, advise against addressing the Big Bang, that studying existence is fine, but the beginning of the universe is God's domain. Hawking, who was to follow the pope on stage, was presenting a paper on just that subject. He did express worry that he would offend his Holiness, but some things are more important.

To most people the concept of intelligent design is laughable on its face and in the context of a scientific curriculum, it is even more so.

Missouri's own Rep. Cynthia Davis (R-O'Fallon) tried to introduce ID legislation in the last House session. While it failed to even move out of committee its mere introduction should speak volumes about the scientific education of our legislators.

Why this has even risen to the level of a legitimate debate is puzzling. It is a theological proposal, plain an simple. Webster defines supernatural as
1 : of or relating to an order of existence beyond the visible observable universe; especially : of or relating to God or a god, demigod, spirit, or devil.
Metaphysics and theology deal with the supernatural while the physicists, chemists and others figure out the building blocks of reality. Attempting to mash the two together to further some religious end does everyone a disservice.

- Murphy

Thursday, August 04, 2005

Name your price....

An amendment was added to the energy bill that would ensure the continued export of weapons grade uranium to foreign countries. The material is used in medial reactors to create isotopes for medical procedures. The reactors, however, are not required to meet the same standards as U.S. facilities. The amendment was added by Senator Burr (R-N.C.) a recipient of large amounts of money from industry lobbyists.
The Burr Amendment -- named for its sponsor, Sen. Richard Burr (R-N.C.) -- would reverse a 13-year-old U.S. policy banning exports of weapons-grade uranium unless the recipients agree to start converting their reactors to use less-dangerous uranium. The Senate rejected the measure last month after critics in both parties warned that it would accelerate the worldwide proliferation of nuclear materials, but a House-Senate conference committee agreed this week to include it in the final bill
This came up earlier but other things had to be attended to. In the intervening time, Billmon over at Whiskey Bar has a scathing indictment of the level of overt corruption that has descended upon the Republican controlled Congress. While he in no way minces words when it comes to taking the few remaining Democrats to task, or the historic fact of corruption in Congress, he saves his best work for the current leadership, the Republican Party.

The New Republicanism was began its gallup to the top following the promise of Newt Gingrich and other Republicans that they would clean house and evict the gluttonous Democrats who had long been feeding off the public trough. What was quickly discovered in Washington (though has for some reason been left out of much of the reporting) is that the Republicans were not trying to drive out the Democrats for abusing their positions, but because they were taking up all the room.

Indeed there may even have been a bit of professional disgust at work as well. The Democrat-controlled congress had its pork and its corruption, but they never could have dreamed of the 19th century style grifting the Republican leadership knew was possible. As the lobbyist Jack Abramoff and House Majority Leader Tom DeLay have demonstrated, there is some serious money to be made if only you can drop any pretense of possessing scruples.

Abramoff went so far as to enlist the former wunderkind of the Christian Coalition, Ralph Reed, to lobby Christian groups to push the legislators to shut down tribal casinos. Abramoff then went to the casinos and promised to help get them up and running again, for a price.

DeLay has his own machine up and running. Nearly the entire lobbying enclave of Washington is now represented by Republicans. Some are former Congressmen, some are former staffers. DeLay let it be known that nothing would get done on the Hill unless the lobbying firms hired his people and contributed to his pet projects. A lobbyist is, by trade, unscrupulous and whatever is best for business is how it is done. DeLay knew that and he turned the tables on the lobbying groups.

Before, politicians felt they needed the lobbyists. The perks and contributions they provided allowed a successful Congressman to enjoy his position and keep his campaigns financed. DeLay showed the lobbyists that they needed him. No access means no work for a lobbyist.

While their success is impressive, the resulting atmosphere is one of unrestricted abandon. Once power and contributions become the only coin of the realm, any form of decorum went out the window. Bi-partisanship? Gone. Bribery on the floor of the House? In.

Now we have a case of the United States exporting material that we (allegedly) went to war to keep out of Saddam's hands. The industry's argument is that converting the medical reactors so they can use lower-quality uranium is very expensive and therefore it is easier to simply provide the higher grade material.

The current cost of the Iraq invasion is over $200 billion and over 1,800 American lives.

Any time you hear a Republican Senator say that national security is the number one concern of his, ask him how he voted on the Burr Amendment to the Energy Bill.

- Murphy

Wednesday, August 03, 2005

Hunter Brumfield

I am not sure what to say about the passing of Hunter Brumfield except, damn. Too damn short.

I knew Hunter off-and-on for 10 years. We were never all that close, but we spent some good times talking over the years. I'd often run into him strolling down South Grand, we'd sit out in front of Mangia or CBGB and chew the fat for a few.

Hunter was a genuine original. He was always searching for new understanding and he wanted to bring everyone with him. If he couldn't take you, he'd make sure you knew the story or play you the song.

A born storyteller, a good person and a great loss.

He will be sorely missed.

Keep him, his family and friends in your thoughts.

- Murphy


Some other comments on Hunter's passing:
STL Streets.
Pretty War STL.

Watching the watchers?

The Political Eye asks an important question:
The EYE may be missing something, but when a police department is admitting that it has fudged crime reports, is conducting illegal background checks for organizations, and has had its tactics of rounding up homeless people declared unconstitutional, somebody at the top needs to be held accountable.

...

So, now inquiring EYES want to know why there have been no calls for an investigation of the police department by Slay or his fellow members of the Police Commission?
There is an ongoing and contentious debate over the possible appointment of a civilian review board for the Saint Louis Police Department. While the department is hesitant to allow such oversight, incidents like these only add to public pressure.

Mayor Francis Slay and the author of the civilian review legislation, Alderman Terry Kennedy (18th Ward), are in agreement that a review board can bring an additional level of oversight and provide the people of St. Louis another way to have their grievances addressed. They differ in whether the members should be elected or appointed, however. Slay believes that electing members would only create more tension and increased divisiveness.

Despite the best intentions, anyone who has seen St. Louis politics in action will have a hard time arguing that it will not quickly spread to the review board elections.

While the SLPD is certainly wary of having another set of eyes looking over their shoulder, the opacity with which the SLPD deals with incidents will only add to some people's suspicions and increase the pressure for the review board.

Police work is difficult, dangerous and far from clean. The public needs to remember the difficult position the officers often find themselves in and consider that before assuming there is an inherent animus to their actions.

The recent abhorrent comments from two DJs on 100.3 The Beat advising on tactics to disable a police officer and keep them from calling for help should highlight to everyone the environment the SLPD operates in on a daily basis. They are asked to deal with everything we are either unable or unwilling to handle and face a constant barrage of criticism.

Some criticism is justified. There are a few bad officers who shouldn't wear a badge. However, much of the criticism stems from mistakes made by officers trying to do their best in a bad situation.

That said, the SLPD needs to open itself up and take strong public action when it needs to be taken. A civilian review board may help relieve some of the animosity directed towards the department, but the department would do even better by being up-front and proactive when problems arise.

- Murphy